March 8, 2015

Kierkegaard and Nietzche on LDS.NET

(I just looked at the "Buzz" tab for this critique)

Kierkegaard:


Principles:


  • Kierkegaard believed that people should be congruent with their moral beliefs. 
  • Kierkegaard taught about how to teach people to be authentic to their moral beliefs. When teaching someone about the obligation they have to their moral beliefs, you cannot just preach to them, you need to help them move into a more vibrant relation to his or her own convictions. You need to get down to their level and create action. 
  • Kierkegaard believed the ideal of objectivity held by scientific researchers subtracted self-concern which was the taproot of our best selves. 

Applications:

  •  A social website should be authentic.  Your users should trust you to live up to the image you present (and hopefully your image is a good one). 
  • The buzz page definitely lives up to the image of the website, in that it provides interesting content for LDS members.  I found myself clicking on videos as soon as I pulled it up.
  • A social website should drop to their level and help people move. A social website should help people move from believing in something (having values) to taking action.  For instance, Facebook helps people not only believe that connecting with old friends is a good thing, but actually do it. 
  •  This page helps people to act consistent with their values by allowing them explore current events within the Mormon community, and even has a link to LDS share which lets people share the Gospel online.  

  • People should be able to look out for their interests.  A social website should allow for each individual to truly dive in and feel that they are able to keep their own self-interest in mind while using it.  
  • By making the Buzz page so diverse, it allows people with all sorts of interests to find a purpose there.  However, the tabs that are listed in the drop down menu are again listed at the top in a semi-chaotic fashion and in a different order from the drop down menu.  This isn't very friendly to users.  It makes it less fun to try to sort through them and select the option you are most interested in. 

Nietzche:

Principles:


  • When you create something, you should create it with the belief that the viewer/listener is a creator themselves. 

Applications:

  • When designing a social website, make it for users as if they are website designers themselves. (If you are writing, write as if your readers are writers, if you are dancing, dance as if your audience are dancers themselves.  Basically just assume your consumers will be critical and intelligent about the subject themselves.)
  • I am no web designer, but if the web designers built this as if the users would be web designers, I do not feel they did a very good job.  I feel that they made quite a few mistakes and bad design choices that even an untrained eye can see. 



No comments:

Post a Comment